Ask a kid what their favorite food is, and you’ll likely get one of three answers: chicken tenders, hamburgers, or pizza. And while it’s fine to order something like Domino’s or Papa Johns when you don’t feel like cooking, sometimes you might want something a little better. Or if you’re out and about with the family, and you’re looking for something that everyone will like — something that isn’t a chain — where should you go?
Don’t worry. We’ve got you covered, with all the best pizza spots across South Central PA, from Hershey to Lancaster, and everything in between. So when you’re wondering what the best pizza place in Harrisburg is, or where to get pizza in Lebanon, you know where to look!
READ: Best Local Coffee Shops in South Central PA
Jump to: CUMBERLAND COUNTY – DAUPHIN COUNTY – LANCASTER COUNTY – LEBANON COUNTY – YORK COUNTY
Pizza in Cumberland County
- Villa Roma, New Cumberland: Authentic Italian with pizza, pasta, subs, and more.
- Seve-N-Dots, Carlisle: Artisan brewery and stone-baked pizza, award-winning chili, wraps, subs, and more.
- Sophia’s Pizzeria, New Cumberland: Founded by Sicilian immigrants, and home of the famous 28-inch pie!
- Napoli Pizza, Carlisle: Italian family-run restaurant with tons of variety, from slices to subs and salads.
- Miseno Pizza & Ristorante, Carlisle: A variety of pizzas are offered here, as well as salads, subs, calzones, and even catering options.
- Little Mario’s, Mechanicsburg: Homemade pizza, stromboli, salads, and more using fresh ingredients.
- Amore at Arcona, Mechanicsburg: Sicilian-style pies in a family-run restaurant which prides itself on quality over quantity.
- Giuseppe’s Brothers, Camp Hill: Locally-owned restaurant of over 20 years serving fresh pizza, stromboli, and more.
- Amici’s Pizza, Mechanicsburg: Family-run business with pies, wings, and even a Nutella pizza for dessert!
Pizza in Dauphin County
- Two Brothers, Harrisburg: Popular local spot offering pies, sandwiches, subs, wings, and more.
- Palermo’s Pizza, Hershey: Try out a taste of Italy offering slices, garlic knots, subs, and desserts.
- Jo-Jo’s Pizza, Hershey and Hummelstown: Homemade dough, sauce, and fresh ingredients for thin-crust, Sicilian, and Neapolitan pies.
- Piazza Sorrento, Hershey: Award-winning restaurant serving regional and classic Italian food, using locally-sourced ingredients.
- Bellia’s Pizza, Harrisburg: Unique, flavorful pies with New York-style slices.
- Fenicci’s, Hershey: Award-winning restaurant which has been a Hershey staple for decades, operating since 1935.
- Doughboy’s Pizzeria, Halifax: Local staple offering pasta, pies, and plenty more!
- Mangia Mangia, Hershey: Sicilian owners run this spot, where each family-style dish is made from scratch.
- Bacco Pizzeria and Wine Bar, Harrisburg: Traditional Sicilian cuisine with brick-oven pizzas and old-fashioned cocktails.
- Yum Pizza, Harrisburg: Friendly staff treats you like family in this spot where everything is homemade.
- Gennaro’s Pizza, Harrisburg: No-frills atmosphere serving up incredible pies with warm and welcoming service.
Pizza in Lancaster County
- Rosa Rosa Pizzeria, Lancaster: Family-owned restaurant with an Italian market, serving up dishes like spaghetti pizza and gelato.
- Nino’s Pizzeria & Ristorante, Millersville: Traditional spot using fresh ingredients, with pizza, paninis, subs, and more.
- Antonio’s Pizza House, Lancaster: Family-owned pizzeria with pies, stromboli, subs, salads, and pasta.
- Pizzeria 211, Lancaster: Fun spot serving Detroit-style pies and cheese steaks.
- House of Pizza, Willow Street: Family owned and operated since 1980 serving slices, stromboli, grinders, and more.
- Slugger’s Pizzeria, Lancaster: Located near Clipper Stadium, it’s the perfect place to grab a pie before seeing a Lancaster Barnstormers game.
- Francesco’s Pizza and Restaurant, Manheim: Sicilian sisters serving classic and specialty pies as well as pasta, subs, and more in a family-friendly atmosphere.
- House of Pizza, Lancaster: Award-winning pizzeria operating since the 1980s serving New England-style pies, as well as stromboli and other Italian favorites.
- Two Cousins Pizza Ristorante Italiano, Stevens: Family from Carini, Italy, with every pie made from scratch and baked in a brick oven.
- Little Nicki’s Pizza, Ephrata: Classic Italian fare as well as other options like wings and corn nuggets.
- Nino’s Italian Restaurant, Lititz: New York-style pizza, salad, pastas, and more.
- Pasquale’s, Lancaster: Made-to-order Italian food in a casual, family-friendly setting.
- Salt ‘n Pepper Italian Bistro, Lancaster: Italian couple operates this brand-new bistro with homemade sauce in a cozy atmosphere. It’s also BYOB!
- Strasburg Pizza, Strasburg: Family-owned business serving thin-crust pizza, subs, salads, and more.
- LUCA Italian Kitchen, Lancaster: Farm-driven restaurant with a wood-burning hearth and Neapolitan oven with handmade pizza and pasta.
- Lititz Pizza Company, Lititz: Vintage diner-style setup serving tons of Italian offerings, including gluten-free pies.
Pizza in Lebanon County
- Infinito’s Pizza Buffet, Lebanon: Local family-owned pizza buffet chain with affordable, all-you-can-eat offerings.
- Gabby’s Italian Bistro, Lebanon: Homey spot featuring pizza, pasta, and plenty of Italian desserts to make your little ones happy.
- J&S Pizza, Annville: Family run for over 20 years, their pizza has tons of possible toppings, as well as pasta, subs, and more.
- Bartolo’s Pizza, Palmyra: Casual setting serving Italian food using fresh ingredients.
- Mancino’s Pizza and Catering, Lebanon: Italian entrepreneurs opened this local spot for over 40 years, and it’s still operated by the same family.
- Fabio and Joe’s, Palmyra: Small, unassuming pizza joint with huge portions of delicious food.
- Justino’s, Newmanstown: Pizza, sandwiches, subs, wings, stromboli, and more — and they deliver!
Pizza in York County
- Joe’s Pizza Plaza, York: Open since 1963, their pies and pastas are made with fresh ingredients, and they also offer Italian ice to finish up your meal!
- Pizza al Bacio, York: Family owned and operated by Sicilian immigrants, specializing in not only pizza and pasta, but an atmosphere themed on making everyone feel like family.
- Nonno’s Pizza, Dillsburg: Fresh, homemade pies also serving wings, cheese steaks, and more.
- Archetype Pizza, York: They offer crispy, thin, lightly charred pizza, as well as GearHouse Brewing Co. beer and a full bar.
- Giovanni’s Pizza, Hanover: Sicilian immigrant opened this local spot with high-quality, authentic pizza and Italian food.
- Memory Lane Pizza, York: Pies made with fresh dough and ingredients, and also serving subs, calzones, pizza, and more.
- Marino’s Pizza and Pasta House, York: Authentic Italian cuisine since 1982, with recipes passed down through the Sicilian family owners.
- Central Pizza and Catering, Red Lion: Owned and operated by a family with roots in Sicily, serving New York-style pizza in a cozy atmosphere.
